Everything OddWay knows about. Narrow it down by what you're after, or where you're going.
Real events too strange to have made the textbook.
Moundsville, WV
Built by Adena people around 250–150 B.C., Grave Creek Mound is one of the largest surviving conical burial mounds of its culture and required the movement of tens of thousands of tons of earth. A free state museum beside the mound interprets West Virginia archaeology and the people who built it.
Peabody, MA
Albert DeSalvo, who confessed to being the Boston Strangler, is buried in Puritan Lawn Memorial Park. DNA later linked him to the murder of Mary Sullivan, although historians and investigators have long questioned whether he was responsible for every killing attributed to the Strangler. Visit only during cemetery hours.
Middlebury, VT
A Middlebury cemetery contains the burial place of an ancient Egyptian mummy once owned by Middlebury College. After deterioration made the remains unsuitable for continued display, the thousands-of-years-old individual was given a modern Vermont burial.
New Haven, CT
Former Yale president Arthur Twining Hadley was reportedly buried wearing a Japanese samurai costume given to him during his travels. The grave itself is understated, but the bizarre burial detail has made it one of New Haven's stranger cemetery stories.
Mount Airy, NC
Chang and Eng Bunker, the conjoined twins whose fame popularized the term “Siamese twins,” settled in North Carolina, married sisters, raised large families, and became farmers. They are buried together beneath a shared marker in the White Plains Baptist Church cemetery.
Bridgeport, CT
Charles Sherwood Stratton, the internationally famous performer promoted by P.T. Barnum as General Tom Thumb, is buried in Mountain Grove Cemetery. A life-size statue of the diminutive entertainer stands atop his monument, making the grave immediately recognizable.
Concord, NH
Concord teacher Christa McAuliffe was selected for NASA's Teacher in Space Project and died with the crew of Space Shuttle Challenger in 1986. Her grave remains in Concord and is part of the city's enduring connection to her life and legacy. Visit respectfully during cemetery hours; the grave is in Block M, Lot 51L.
Charlotte, NC
Conjoined twins Daisy and Violet Hilton spent much of their lives performing in vaudeville, sideshows, and film before eventually settling in Charlotte. They died within days of one another during the 1968 flu pandemic and share a grave at Forest Lawn West Cemetery.
Plattsburg, MO
Senator David Rice Atchison is buried beneath a monument that repeats the long-running claim that he was 'president for one day' during the 1849 presidential transition. Historians do not regard him as an actual U.S. president, but the story remains one of Missouri's most durable political-history oddities.
Rural Retreat, VA
Dr. Charles T. Pepper is buried in Mountain View Cemetery, and a long-running local story connects him to the naming of the Dr Pepper soft drink through pharmacist Wade Morrison. The exact origin of the beverage's name remains disputed, but the grave gives travelers a physical stop for one of Virginia's most persistent soda-history stories.
Berlin, MA
Don Featherstone, designer of the iconic plastic pink lawn flamingo, is buried beneath a marker decorated with a flock of flamingos and an inscription crediting him as their original creator. It is an appropriately kitschy final memorial for one of America's most recognizable lawn ornaments.
Sharon, MA
William Rosenberg, founder of Dunkin' Donuts, is buried in Sharon Memorial Park. The otherwise conventional grave gives Massachusetts travelers a physical endpoint to the story of a regional doughnut-and-coffee business that grew into an international chain. Check cemetery access rules before visiting.
Owosso, MI
Felix Schlag won the 1938 competition to design the Jefferson nickel, creating the basic portrait and Monticello design used for decades. His grave in Oak Hill Cemetery is marked with a large representation of the coin, and visitors sometimes leave nickels on the stone.
Florence, SC
Florena Budwin is traditionally identified as a woman who disguised herself as a man in order to accompany her husband into Confederate military service. Captured and imprisoned, she died in 1865 and is buried at Florence National Cemetery; elements of her story remain debated, but the grave has become a local historical curiosity. Cemetery: https://www.cem.va.gov/cems/nchp/florence.asp
Middletown, RI
George Mendonsa, widely identified as the sailor in Alfred Eisenstaedt's famous V-J Day Times Square photograph, is buried in St. Columba Cemetery. His grave marker reproduces the instantly recognizable embrace in etched stone. The coordinate routes to the cemetery; visitors should follow cemetery rules and locate the individual grave respectfully.
Charlton, MA
John 'Grizzly' Adams, the nineteenth-century mountain man and animal trainer, is buried beneath a monument topped by a carved bear. His traveling menageries and exaggerated frontier image helped turn him into a lasting American folk character.
Charlotte, NC
John King was killed after being crushed by an escaped circus elephant in Charlotte. His gravestone carries a carved elephant, turning an already bizarre death into one of the city’s strangest cemetery markers.
Whiteville, NC
Conjoined twins Millie and Christine McKoy were born enslaved in North Carolina in 1851 and later became internationally known performers billed as the “Two-Headed Nightingale.” Their shared grave in Welches Creek Cemetery bears an inscription describing “two hearts that beat as one.” Cemetery coordinates: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q68101741
Manchester, VT
Near the summit of Equinox Mountain is the granite grave of Mr. Barbo, the beloved dog of industrialist Joseph George Davidson. The unusually elaborate canine memorial recounts how Barbo was killed by a hunter in 1955; reaching it requires seasonal access on Skyline Drive.
Carolina Beach, NC
Robert E. Harrill became a coastal celebrity after living for years in an abandoned World War II bunker near Fort Fisher and welcoming thousands of curious visitors. His grave preserves the story of the self-styled Fort Fisher Hermit after his mysterious death in 1972.
Bucksport, ME
Sarah Ware was murdered in 1898 in a case that remains one of Bucksport’s enduring unsolved crimes. Her severed head was reportedly retained as evidence for decades before eventually being returned for burial near her cemetery marker.
New Boston, NH
Seventeen-year-old Sevilla Jones was murdered by Henry Sargent in 1854 while walking to school. Her unusually blunt gravestone names Sargent as her killer and describes the shooting, turning the marker into a permanent public accusation. Sargent is buried only a short distance away in the same cemetery.
Barnegat Light, NJ
Sinbad served aboard the Coast Guard cutter Campbell for years, surviving combat and becoming one of the service's most famous animal mascots. A memorial and burial site at Barnegat Light preserves the story of the mixed-breed dog whose service career included World War II.
Laurinburg, NC
Cancetto “Spaghetti” Farmica was a carnival worker whose unclaimed body reportedly spent years preserved at a Laurinburg funeral home before finally being buried in 1972. Local accounts say his grave was sealed beneath an extraordinary amount of concrete, giving the obscure showman one of North Carolina’s strangest burial stories.
